St Mary's Spotlight: Andy

FEAST SUN. AUG. 8th

St. Mary's St Mary's Feast of the Assumption T-Shirts87th Annual Feast of the Assumption
12 noon to 10 PM
Join us!

At this year's Feast of the Assumption, in addition to our regular Mass and a beautiful procession with our new barque lovingly made last year by a parishioner, we will also have:

  • fun stuff for the kids, like inflatables
  • trackless train  for the kids
  • brand new games for adults and kids
  • hay ride (see photo below)
  • musical entertainment (great bands, right)
  • seafoodFeast of the Assumption Day Two
  • chicken bbq
  • yummy baked goods
  • water ice from Toni's Treats
  • funnel cake
  • beer & Plagido's wine
  • Chinese auction
  • 50-50 raffle
  • some fireworks at the end of the night
  • commemorative t-shirts, $12 (above right)
And we're sure we've missed some things....oh yeah, cheeze fries, cotton candy, snow cones, and more! It will definitely be a good time! Hope to see you there.

                                                                                              

Feast of the Assumption Day Two

Testing out the hay rides at last year's feast

Feast of the Assumption Day Two

This year, inflatables, train, & hay ride will be available
for an all-day wristband, $12, or individually.


August scenes of St Mary's

A brand new, beautiful creche for our Rosary
Garden's Nativity scene was generously provided
by a parishioner in preparation for this year's Feast.

St. Mary's parishioners have been hard at work! But not only building booths...

  • Joanne always puts together wonderful baskets for the Chinese Auction,
  • Marlene sells our 50-50 tickets,
  • Jeanie and Ramona, among others, work hard on the Rosary and other gardens.
  • Steve and Jim prepare the grounds.
  • Jim also helps build the new booths, organizes the talent show, plays the organ, rehearses the choir, and plays with his band.
  • Bill and another Steve help organize the chicken barbecue.
  • Steve gave the feast buildings a new coat of paint and cleaned them out.
  • Tim and the Knights handle the seafood and beer.
  • Diane covers the "snack" foods like funnel cake, cotton candy, and cheeze fries.
  • Carmella organizes the cakes and baked goods.
  • Leah does...well, everything...signs, permits, tents, donations, all level of organization, and on and on and on.
  • Dan and Mike get the tractor and hay ride ready, among many other things.
We are blessed to have so many committed parishioners who do these things for love of their parish and the Blessed Mother! We couldn't begin to list them all. For our little church, this high level of participation is supposed to be exactly what the bishop wants. Problem is, we're volunteers, not paid staff they like to call "ministers." (And, of course, we're not a huge "McChurch.") We tend to do things for love, not for money. So many of the people we've mentioned have spent their own money, not to mention tons of time, to make this Feast a success. Now that is real community, not something artificially concocted. We don't need to "make community work," a phrase I've recently read in a nearby merging parish's bulletin, because ours already does, even with zero pastoral support.

The Booths:
Joe puts together the adbook, which is a ton of work in and of itself, but he also built our beautiful barque for the Blessed Mother last year. This year he's built new booths for food and games, and boy is he a perfectionist. In one of the pictures you'll see Jim, wearer of many hats, finishing up with some of the last things on the booths. Take a look at our little slideshow.
 

Created with flickr slideshow from softsea.

Comment on a comment

Andy Walton, Diocesan spinmaster (spokesman), was quoted in the CP article we linked to yesterday as saying, "the [law] suit was premature because 'no (merger) decree has been issued and there's been no alteration of the parish.'" Well that's an interesting perspective, isn't it? Using this logic, all "core team" meetings and other plans to close, consolidate, and otherwise alter parishes and churches are also premature. Of course, if a decree had been issued, they would argue that if a complaint was to have been registered it should have been raised before the decree was issued. Let's face it. Any parish who sees the writing on the wall needs to act quickly and proactively, not after the ink is dry and the wrecking machines are in place. When wrong is being done, we are obliged to speak out about it. Using Divine law as a guide, all plans to destroy God's churches and, as the current Diocesan administration intends to do, change the Catholic Faith to resemble evangelical protestantism, are always premature since they are entirely unwarranted and wrong. But it doesn't appear the Diocese is using Divine law as its guide, but instead corporate law, or something equally ungodly.
My parents were married at Sacred Heart Church in Vineland, the church my ancestors helped to build (both the original Sacred Heart as well as the "new" Sacred Heart, that is). My grandmother's side was from St. Mary's Malaga northern Italian "cousin," the East Vineland St. Mary's. (Apparently, they  used virtually identical blueprints for both St. Mary's churches.) Anyway, my mother went all through Sacred Heart grade school and high school way back when it was...well, back when there were habited religious sisters teaching there.

My mom died back in 2000 just after she turned 50 following a long, long, long battle with cancer, and my father has recently remarried. He let me borrow the wedding album awhile back to scan in these pictures of their wedding day. As you can see, they were clearly awesome! This was back in 1974, the height of blue eyeshadow, side burns, chunky heels, and general awesomeness all around.

On a serious note, it is nothing short of a complete and utter travesty that the bishop wants this beautiful church, every bit as beautiful and comparable in size as the cathedral in Camden, closed. It is totally unnecessary. This is the sort of thing that devastates people and drives them from the Faith in complete disgust, mistrust, disbelief. But hey, I guess it looks too...Catholic. Time to make way for the generic McMegachurch. Change the mass, change the church, change the religion. And hey, St. Isidore's has got plenty of land behind it...

Sacred Heart Wedding
This is my beautiful mother. As you can see, she liked wildflowers
so it was very appropriate that she chose daisies for her bouquet.
The confusing part about this picture is, if that's my mom in the
foreground sporting the blue eyeshadow and faux Victorian
dress, who's that chick standing next to my dad at the altar?!
Super duper special effects! Those were the fabulous 70's!

Wedding, Sacred Heart, Vineland
Here you see my wonderful grandparents. I love them. My
grandmother, the one in the blue dress, was a school teacher
way back in the days of the one-room schoolhouse. And yes, she
had strawberry blonde hair and green eyes and yes she was
100% Italian. My grandfather owned DeMarchi Printing on West Ave.
They came from large farm families. Great ravioli and pizzelle,
among other things. My dad is on the left with his dad standing
behind him. Check out my dad's platform shoes and lambchops.
Whoa! Standing in the center of the photo is one of my grandfather's
sisters. A wonderful woman, she passed away only last year.

Sacred Heart Wedding
This is a nice view of the church from the choir loft. I remember
going to Sacred Heart with my grandparents for mass. We'd always
sit on the left hand side (not pictured above, but below).

Sacred Heart Vineland Wedding
Here you can see my dad's mustache and ruffly shirt. Standing in
the background is my godmother, Susan, with the long, black
hair and floppy hat. By the way, we didn't scan in the picture
wrong, that fuzziness on the sides is another funkadelic
special mood effect. Oooh yeah, baby!

With this ring...
The exchange of rings. The priest, according to the marriage
certificate, is a Fr. Rush. I don't believe I've ever met him, but as you
can see back then, he too, was awesome. Cool sideburns, Fr. Rush!

Newleyweds
Particularly before she got sick, my mom was a tiny little thing.
When my grandmother died we found my mom's wedding dress
in the cedar closet. I fit into it in 7th grade. Geese! Here you
can also see the amazing heads of hair on Fr. Rush and the
altar boys. Wow!

The Wedding Party 1974
Here's the wedding party. I forget where this picture was taken.
Perhaps Parvin. On the extreme left is my sister's godmother,
Patty and next to her my godmother, Susan. Next to my dad is
some guy he obviously is not friends with anymore (my guess
is "Skip"), but boy he does have a great beard, huh? Next to that
is my dad's friend, Pat, my dad's youngest brother (the long hair),
and on the extreme end my dad's middle brother. How do you like
those brides maid dresses with the floppy hats?!

Needless to say I listened to a lot of Bee Gees growing up (which I still hate). Anything falsetto just turns my stomach. (Sorry mom.) I probably don't need to tell you that I am pictured in my nursery school photo with plaid, corduroy bell bottoms. Sigh. Apparently this song was recorded in 1977, but it just seems appropriate.




If you like these fabulous pictures, check out my parents floating in a brandy snifter. Cool effects, man!
You may read the entire article here, but we will be quoting from sections of this interesting essay, The American Church, Is it Here?, in anticipation of our look at Pope Saint Pius X's 1906 encyclical against the modernists entitled, Pascendi Dominici Gregis. The aforementioned article (and perhaps the encyclical, too!) may be perceived by some as radical, but the author's points are well made and ring startlingly familiar. It looks as if the original article was written in 1983.

Within his essay, author Michael Davies summarizes a 1981 article in the Homiletic and Pastoral Review. This article was written by an anonymous priest and discusses "the plight of the papist priest;" that is, the priest who is obedient to the pope and the magisterium (holy teaching authority) of the Church. Sadly, twenty-eight years later, you may find yourself recognizing many of these conditions as unfortunately present here in the American Catholic church. (However, it should be noted that under Pope Benedict XVI there is greater hope.)

1) Many American dioceses are ruled by bishops who are either Modernists or who submit to Modernist control of their diocese;

2) Modernists have a "lock-tight" control of the diocesan bureaucracy;

3) Priests who are loyal to the Pope have been reduced to a minority of one-eighth of the diocesan clergy;

4) These priests are isolated, ridiculed and have no hope of advancement;

5) Most seminaries are totally Modernist, and the students who are ordained from them are totally-programmed Modernists;

6) Modernist influence is particularly dominant in the fields of liturgy, catechetics, and the diocesan press;

7) The situation is certain to worsen;

8) Many American dioceses are already totally alienated from the Holy See;

9) Given the present process of consultation prior to episcopal appointments, there is no prospect of orthodox priests being promoted to the episcopate.

Further, the author Davies quotes states the following:

About half the clergy comprise the swing area: a vast mushy no-man's land where the priests will flip-flop wherever and whenever convenience dictates. At present this means conforming to the radical Modernist leadership. For some of these men, a nostalgia for Rome surfaces now and then, but is quickly submerged. Theirs is the tired refrain: "But this is what the bishop wants, and we took a vow of obedience to our bishop."
Therefore what we really have is disobedience to tradition, disobedience to clear Catholic Church teaching, and in its place a false obedience to sadly misled bishops who in turn mislead the faithful with the cooperation of their priests.

In our particular case, we have the lowering in status of our churches to "just buildings," as easily dispensable as old candy wrappers. In their stead, we face the prospect of what we already see in existence throughout our own and other dioceses: new, modern[ist] structures that are antiseptic, cold, round or semi-circular so as to promote the elevation of "community" above all things.* Said structures are typically lacking in ornamentation worthy of God, but replete with CatholicChurchSupply.com type furnishings. Such generic "auditorium"-like sanctuaries are often without statues and side altars, absent truly beautiful teaching art, yet manage to find space for the addition of un-catholic devices such as audio visual equipment and plenty of room beside the altar for rock bands and grand pianos. Worst of all is the removal Our Lord and Savior in the tabernacle to a side altar, separate chapel, or God knows where.

We know from historical precedent that the first thing "reformers" do is to destroy church architecture and furnishings. They destroy art and statuary, they desecrate holy things, they even torch buildings. All this and more has been done, and always in the name of progress, of Reformation. They know, perhaps intuitively, that the easiest way to change people's religion and how they worship is to change where they worship.

Yes, these structures are more recognizably non-denominational protestant in character than Catholic. And when we change church architecture so dramatically, we change the focus of the mass and the focus of our prayer, not to mention Catholic tradition and identity generally. When we change the focus of the mass, we succeed in changing the mass and, consequently, our very Faith.
*We shall see that Pope St. Pius X addresses this at length in his Encyclical on the Doctrine of the Modernists.

To be continued.

Re: "Cares deeply" (letters, Sept. 2).

Andrew Walton, spokesman for the Camden Diocese, implies (erroneously) that St. Gregory's in Magnolia is a struggling parish. This could not be further from the truth, unless he is referring to the morale of our parishioners since the announcement that our church would be closing.

Financially, St. Gregory's is not struggling. We are probably on better financial footing than Mary Mother of The Church in Bellmawr, the parish we will merge with under the reconfiguration plan.

Our mortgage was paid off many years ago. And our weekly collections and stipends bring in enough money to cover our parish expenses and then some -- including contributions monthly to diocesan debt and other special collections.

I believe the proceeds from the sale of St. Gregory's assets are earmarked to pay off or reduce the debt of Mary Mother of The Church, which is the true struggling parish. Yet, Bishop Joseph Galante wants St. Gregory's to merge with this parish. And therein lies the hurt we feel.

It makes no sense. Mary Mother of the Church should merge with St. Gregory's, not the other way around. Or it seems to make more sense if it were merged with the other parish in its own community.

In addition, our dissatisfaction with the bishop's decision is not entirely about the assets our parishioners worked hard to pay for and that we are about to lose. Our struggle is more about our loving parish community and the fond memories that are about to be snuffed out. God bless us all.

WALTER ZUBRZYCKI

Magnolia

Read the CP letter to the editor here


Good for you, Walter! Andy Walton and all the rest of them ought to be ashamed of themselves. God bless St. Gregory's.
Here's a letter to the editor from Diocese of Camden spinmaster, Andy Walton. Don't laugh right away, read it first.

Re: "Do not care" (letters, Aug. 27).
The letter writer from Magnolia,St. Gregory Roman Catholic Church whose struggling parish is merging with two nearby parishes, suggested that Bishop Joseph Galante, his priest advisers, deanery planning teams, planning commission and Core Teams "do not care" about the pain being felt by parishioners when their parishes merge.

The feelings of loss that accompany change of this kind are not being ignored. In fact, unlike other dioceses that have moved far more quickly with parish reconfigurations, the bishop insisted there be a period of 12 to 24 months before he issued decrees formally establishing new parishes. He did this in recognition of the sense of loss he knew would be experienced and to give parishes adequate time to prepare to come together.

During this time, he has heard personally from parishioners in every part of the diocese and has acknowledged the disappointment many naturally feel. The fact is, if he didn't care, he would not be taking steps to address the needs of Catholics in South Jersey. If he didn't care, he wouldn't be working to reverse downward trends in religious practice.

The fact is, it is precisely because the bishop cares so deeply about the well-being of parishioners and because of his great love for the Church and the people of South Jersey that he has undertaken the effort now under way to strengthen parishes and improve care to the people.

ANDREW WALTON Office of Communications Diocese of Camden Camden

Our Response, Point By Ridiculous Point
St. Gregory's:
Andy's talking about the beautiful St. Gregory's (above) in Magnolia. Galante, McGrath, and Walton "care" so much they seem to have sold the property to Wawa. Who do they think they're fooling? We've got pictures of the surveyors sent to us by a concerned reader back last Christmas. Money talks, and to the tune of 10 million dollars, apparently. Empathy my foot. It's prime real estate.


View Larger Map

"Downward trends in religious practice":
As to the misleading demographic information continually touted by Mr. Walton, we've addressed it numerous times. It's lies. Just look here and here and here. All you have to do is look on a map to see where Magnolia is to know that the Catholic population in that area can only be expanding, not decreasing. We're not talking rural Fairton, Cumberland County here or Dennis Township, Cape May County. We're talking close proximity to Philadelphia in a congested, continually expanding area of South Jersey.

The plain fact is that the Catholic population in NJ and in South Jersey in particular is dramatically increasing. In fact the Catholic population in NJ has increased by at least 2.5% since 1990, by roughly 100,000 people. In Gloucester County alone we're looking at a Catholic increase of at least 20% since 1990. The Catholic population is only decreasing in South Jersey's only true urban centers, Camden and Atlantic City, as illustrated below:

                    Deptford           Salem County                Camden                   Atlantic City

1950                 7,304                 49,508                       124,555                       61,657

1960               17,878                 58,711                       117,159                       59,544

2006-7*          30,529                 66,595                         80,010                      39,684

*most recent available estimate

"Reversing Downward Trends":
Do they really care about reversing supposed downward trends or about justifying their own agenda? If all they care about is giving people what they want, they should stop watering down the Faith and desiring to build protestant style megachurches. And if they are truly targeting young adults, as they should, this group wants one of two things, neither of which the Diocese of Camden is offering: (1) an authentic and unapologetic Christianity, or (2) at the very least, clarity and a lack of hypocrisy. This is why you see the most traditional churches and religious orders growing. Alternately those who are leaving the Church are leaving for a protestantism whose Christianity is clear and faith exacting. Others who leave leave the Faith and stay away out of disgust for the likes of people like Walton and others who pretend religion but in reality have nothing but political motives. See these comments on Andy's letter, for example:

bjd0305:
It is more effective to have fewer churches with more people in them. god is a hell of a businessman
9/2/2009 8:27:08 AM

firebird 7478 replying to bjd0305:

Which is why he's always asking for more money.
9/2/2009 10:41:42 AM
Case in point. House of "Charity" anyone?

"Feelings of Loss that Accompany Change":
We addressed this patronizing attitude just the other day. So we quote ourselves!
They have spewed psychobabble pertaining to the alleged difficulty that we, the laity have coping with change. This kind of patronizing dribble is without merit because it fails to address the purpose of the change and merely holds up "change" as having inherent value. This type of rhetoric attempts to put the Catholic faithful on the defensive, as if we have to prove our ability to healthily cope with change by accepting the destruction of our parishes. The question remains, is the change we are expected to embrace a change toward the Good, toward God's Will, toward God Himself? What are we supposed to be changing to?
"Heard Personally From Parishioners":
And, apparently, listened to few of them. Go ahead and ask St. Gregory's how "listened to" they're feeling right about now. They got "listened" right into closure.
Read the Article by Clicking HERE

I was in Euchristic Adoration yesterday and toward the end of my hour the woman mentioned in the story, Christina Thomasello, approached me inquiring about our church. We'd never met before. Ms. Thomasello just happened to be driving down Route 40 and noticed St. Mary's, and did a U-turn. She was nothing less than amazed. She told me, "This is the most beautiful church I've ever seen!" All I could say was, "I know!"

As it turns out, she and a group of people unhappily find themselves at the center of a controversy. You see, a diverse bunch of people from the Atlantic City area, including people without a thing in the world to call their own or problems none of us wish to face, have been unwittingly transformed by God. Somehow, God drew this unlikely group of people together in their common effort to restore a lovely shrine to Our Lady of Lourdes at Our Lady Star of the Sea.


View Larger Map

Ms. Thomasello showed me a copy of the newspaper article and relayed to me the group's interest not in changing anything at the church or shrine, but in finding out what it once looked like and helping to fix it up. Many in this group have contributed plants, stonework, and a heck of a lot of labor. All this they gave from their own time and effort without any expectation of repayment, just because they wanted to. Strangely, they have encountered much resistence to their efforts from the pastor, Rev. Pham. In their attempts to win his heart, they purchased from their own pockets a lovely statue of St. Bernadette, now the center of this seemingly ridiculous controversy, and had it sent to the rectory as a gift. Of course this strikes us as really odd since people donate things to St. Mary's all the time, eveything from stained glass windows to handywork to statues in the rosary garden to plants to small statues placed around the church. Our shrine room is bursting at the seems with beautiful statues, pictures, and relics of the saints.

Of course, Andy Walton has to chime in with a typically bizarre comment or two. "There's no history of that," (meaning no history of the shrine being dedicated to Our Lady of Lourdes) as if he would have any familiarity with the histor of this parish anyway. (The man lives in Pennsylvania.) But isn't this beside the point? Whatever happened to courtesy? Why alienate the Catholic faithful by rejecting the gift of their time, talents, and gifts?

One has to wonder if the group of people involved were wealthy and influential, the Diocese would look quite differently upon them. With all this talk about wanting to transform the Diocese of Camden's churches into places that throb with "social justice ministries," it seems particularly ironic that they would allow a group of disaffected people to be treated so rudely. And all this talk about trying to win back lapsed Catholics, you would think a thing like this would warm the hearts of the Galante administration. Huh. Guess not.

Mr. Walton concludes with, "It's not her shrine." That's interesting. In my conversation with Thomasello she was mystified by the implication that she believed the shrine belonged to her. However it struck us that if in this "process" of "transforming" the Diocese was to be influenced by the "voice of the people," (which nobody I know truly believes,) then whose churches are they? Whose shrines are they? In the end, they ought to belong to the people who care for them, pray at them, and love them.

But of course, all this talk has nothing to do with politics or property value...


Article below:
 


Church officials say there is no evidence the shrine at Our Lady Star of the Sea in Atlantic City is dedicated to Our Lady of Lourdes. But Christina Thomasello is looking for photos to prove otherwise.

Photo by: Danny Drake

There's an unwelcome guest at a local church rectory: St. Bernadette.

Standing 2 feet tall, a stone statue of the saint sits behind locked doors in the rectory offices.

And because of a spat about a nearby shrine, she has become an unlikely hostage.

When a parishioner at Our Lady Star of the Sea in Atlantic City paid for the statue to be delivered to the parish office earlier this spring, she says, she had hoped to see the figure placed at an outdoor shrine on the church's grounds.

But instead, Christina Thomasello says her prayer for a completed shrine to Our Lady of Lourdes has been derailed.

The pastor there, the Rev. Joseph Pham, disagrees with her plan to build a shrine in a way he says detracts from the church's identity.

And so, when St. Bernadette arrived by priority mail in March, Pham did not put her at the shrine. He held on to her.

"This is a situation where a priest has to balance the need to maintain the integrity of the shrine with the desires of some of the parishioners," said Andy Walton, spokesman for the Catholic Diocese of Camden, who expressed support for Pham's actions.

At the heart of the dispute -- and what keeps Bernadette in a holding pattern -- is a split between local Catholics, who see two interpretations of what the shrine represents.

Stop by the site, at the corner of Atlantic and California avenues, and you will see a tall, pale statue of the Virgin Mary standing in a stone alcove.

A nearby sign says the stone basin by the guardrail contains water from Lourdes, France -- where a peasant girl, Bernadette Soubirous, claimed to see a repeated vision of the Virgin Mary in 1858. Faithful pilgrims now flock to that original site, often in hopes of healing.

But alongside that basin at the Atlantic City site sit decorative anemone and conch shells, clues that the shrine, like the parish, may be dedicated to Our Lady Star of the Sea. The name refers to the Virgin Mary and remains popular in areas with sea-faring heritage.

Thomasello, who refers to the shrine as Our Lady of Lourdes, insisted recently that her motives were to bring the shrine back to its former glory. "I wanted to restore it," she said on a recent afternoon, as she and fellow parishioners Horace Robinson and Robert Carpo Jr. met at the shrine, which she noted dates back to the 1930s.

But other parishioners were not so sure. Mary McConnell, who stopped by the shrine just before noon Sunday, said the Lourdes tributes -- which also include prayer cards and articles about purported miracles performed in France -- were recent additions. "I think they started showing up in December," McConnell said.

Walton said there is no evidence the site is dedicated to the apparitions at Lourdes. "There's no history of that," he said Saturday.

As for allowing Thomasello or others to place a statue there, he said that would open the door to any parishioner customizing a public shrine at their own expense.

"It's not her shrine," Walton said.

As far as Thomasello's hopes to reclaim the statue, Raymond Daiutolo Sr., southern New Jersey representative for the U. S. Postal Service, said laws on mail do not help her case.

Whether or not the package had been addressed to her by name, Daiutolo said, the fact that it was sent to a church -- which qualifies as a business -- meant it could legally be held by staff at the rectory office. "If someone has mail sent to a business address, those mail items technically belong to the business," he said.

Statues of St. Bernadette are big sellers for catalogs that cater to the religious community: Stone or ceramic versions of the saint, traditionally depicted kneeling in prayer, can go for as much as $100.

Walton said Saturday that Pham now wants Thomasello to come and pick up her Bernadette.

Thomasello was not available to respond to that invitation Sunday.

But she previously said she had been searching for photos, which may solve the mystery of the shrine's identity.

"I've heard that there used to be metal letters over the top of the shrine," she said. "We want to know what they said."

If local historians have photos that show a historic Lourdes link, that might allow the homeless St. Bernadette statue to settle there.

But until then, Walton said, the statue was unwanted. "Right now, to have two identities here -- that's just confusing."

E-mail Juliet Fletcher:

JFletcher@pressofac.com




Find more videos like this on Council of Parishes NJ

You'll notice that Andy Walton, diocesan spinmaster, claims it would take millions of dollars to buy or retrofit an appropriate convent. The question remains, why all of a sudden so generous to the sisters? And why is it that any religious sister who has taken a vow of poverty would need a million or multi-million dollar home? And in this case, there are only five! Who do they think they are kidding?

Shame, shame shame on Bishop Galante, Andrew Walton, Roger McGrath, and all those heading the current diocesan administration. From the mouths of the diocesan officials visiting the property in December, they were expecting the home to be used for Bishop Galante.

If five religious sisters warrant a 1.5 million dollar home on 11 acres, an $800,000 expenditure (plus furnishings, etc.), then we the Catholic faithful have a right to worship in the churches our ancestors built! Many if not most of the churches that Galante seeks to close are financially solvent!  Don't believe the lies.
Here is some raw video of the Fox 29 News coverage. In this video you can see how truly huge this property is. There's also a brief story (see clip below). (The 3-car garage alone looks to be roughly the size of our house! With 5 garages, that's one for each sister.  Do they even have that many cars?)



"However, the purchase is upsetting some parishioners who are mad about the spending at a time when parishes are being merged."
Look out for coverage of Bishop Galante's estate fiasco on Fox 29 News tonight (Monday) at 5:00. No matter the coverage, it is good that the media is so interested in shedding light on this important topic. We applaud their efforts to bring people the truth.

It's interesting that so far, no one seems to be buying Andy Walton's story about the estate being purchased for sisters or a retreat center. It's just too unbelievable, especially what with the neighbor, Mr. Langley, being told in December that the house was for the bishop.

AC Press Comments

Here are some recent comments in response to the article regarding the bishop's 1.5 million dollar luxury estate--oh wait, no, "convent"--in Pittsgrove.

As a comment of our own, it has occurred to us that undoubtedly the diocesan administration must be exerting tremendous pressure on the poor sisters at this time, who must truly feel caught between satisfying the bishop's requests and fulfilling their vow of poverty, a promise they made to God. It is outrageous that the chancery would put out a statement supposedly made by Sr. Bernadette, while no one from the media has spoken directly to her, to the best of our knowledge. There is no way of verifying that she actually said what they claim she did.


Press Comments:

Is Andrew Walton coming unwound? His comments are hysterical, not to mention completely contradictory. He's another way our diocese is wasting money. I wonder how much he's getting paid for his "services."

Posted by: hahaha on Sun Mar 15, 2009, 11:28 PM



How much money does Andrew Walton make that he thinks an $800,000 house is a 'modest' living arrangement?

Posted by: elaine on Sun Mar 15, 2009, 11:38 PM


Not to be mean but with all the church and school closings recently and more in the future, why do they need new nuns? What are they going to do?

Posted by: theFlyingNun on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 2:32 AM


wake up parishoners!

YOU'VE BEEN DUPED!!

welcome to CAMP ALTAR BOY!!!

Posted by: no sin no win on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 3:58 AM


Ahhhhhhhh...haters and cafeteria Catholics. Some things you can just go to sleep on.

Posted by: Truth on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 5:13 AM


Isn't this awful when the diocese closes St Nicholas School in Egg Harbor City and wants to shut St Nick's church! This is an outrage!!!!!

Posted by: MaysLandingJane on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 6:14 AM


As with any charity...most donated funds go to administrative costs...I am sure the 'Bishops Annual Appeal' needed a new headquarters to operate from...
counting your gold in a lavish country estate seems
Medival in a way

Posted by: mikeyd__ on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 6:18 AM


simple math:

$8 million divided by 5 nuns = $1.6 million per nun.

talk about HIGH MAINTENANCE BABES!!!

Posted by: collection plate - not! on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 8:21 AM


This purchase gives a whole new meaning to "House of Charity". But seriously, why should I give a dime? They clearly don't need my hard earned money.

Posted by: Maria on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 8:30 AM


from Kenyan grass hut to upscale rural estate.

nice career move girls!

ps: but do they know how use the wet bar and ice maker?

Posted by: papist scam on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 8:31 AM


If you had a bunch of people giving you money every week wouldnt you spend it...They havn't spent it properly in a long time.

I went to Rome on vacation a few years ago and I am getting on the plane walking to my coach seat and what do I see a priest sitting in first class. I know when I searched to purchase those seats were like $15k round trip...I have not given a dime to the church since I saw that

Posted by: scam on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 8:41 AM


Why does this come as a shock to anyone? The Catholic Church is one of the wealthiest entities on the planet! They preach poverty yet acquire lavish property, jewels and artwork all the time. The vatican houses some of the most precious artworks of all time. They are not strapped for cash and never have been. They are considered to be among the larges private land holders in the world, and are estimated to have billions of dollars in banks and stocks around the world. It is one of the biggest businesses on earth. In his newest list of sins that will send you to "you know where," the pope has included accumulating vast wealth, but the Church has been doing that every day since its inception. Interesting, isn't it?

And sorry, but it's not 8 million dollars, it's 800 thousand dollars. Guess the math wasn't so simple for the brain trust who thought he'd make a point. Too funny.

Posted by: Really? on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 8:55 AM


Okay, everyone get your Catholic-bashing out of your system. Just remember when you are done, that Catholics are a very devout group of people. Unfortunately, their leadership is self-serving...just like our politicians. Ever notice that no matter what the group, power corrupts?

Posted by: njstorm on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 9:12 AM


"Spirit of poverty" while living in a $1.5 million dollar home? That's kind of like saying the Bishop has a "Spirit of fasting." Greed, corruption, lies - all from the Catholic heirarchy - it is disheartening to say the least. Bishop Gallante should resign.

Posted by: outraged in ocean city on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 9:32 AM


The church is big business. The road to heaven is paved with good intentions now send me the dollars.

Posted by: executioner1 on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 9:38 AM


I am somewhat familiar with the situation, and can tell you that the sisters are not at all comfortable with the sitaution. This was all Gallante.

Posted by: maverick on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 9:39 AM


If someone wants to know the excess of the hierarchy of the Catholic church in our Diocese, as well as in Philadelphia's, look at the ownership of several beachfront homes in Ventnor ... just a block from where St. James R.C. Church and school faced closings.

And not begrudging just the beachfront property, but the excessive nature INSIDE those homes (yes, I have seen it firsthand).

When the Diocese decided to close St. Augustine School in Ocean City, knowing full well prior to their decision that those students did NOT have another school that could take them, I knew I had given the Diocese my last time.

I think Catholics in this Diocese need to express their displeasure in the only way the Diocese and the Bishop understand ... financially. That is what bought several churches at least temporary reprieves already.

The religion and the faith of Catholics are strong (and yes I am one) ... its the leadership - the human element - that is flawed.

Posted by: truth not rhetoric on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 9:46 AM


There are way tooooo many empty Convents throughout the state to allow this to happen. The house should have been sold or rented for a lot of money.
The Nuns are very nice people who deserve whatever they get however there are many many empty houses in this and other states for them to live in for free.

Posted by: Empty nests' on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 10:02 AM


OK...so here we are with hundreds of billions of OUR dollars going out to greedy banks and business men to "save" them all. This is all OUR money and will cost us and our children for decades to come. I have a great idea. this will eliminate the current billions in debt and settle the national debt. If we just tax the Catholic church on its real estate holding in the U.S. we will raise enough cash to cancel out all the problems. All of the faithful can then empty there wallets into a brass plate on Sunday to help the churches pay there tax bills. Now the church will really now what poverty is like. We pay our tax bills every year now it is there turn. Just look around town next time you take a drive. no matter what town you live in the churches own the nicest land and the nicest homes in the nicest sections of town. Then go home and look at your home and your tax bill and just do some math and you will get an idea of the value of some of this land and structures.

Posted by: njscanner on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 10:03 AM


I am outraged by this article. There are devote Catholics who tried their best in preventing the merger from happening last year. They even poured in money from their personal savings. In return, we here about a eight-hundred thousand dollar convent.

Posted by: Listen here on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 10:29 AM


This is appalling! There are many, many underused convents in the diocese. The diocese has a retreat center in Blackwood and to believe we would trust they're purchase of this property as a 'future retreat center' is ridiculous.

What is it with this bishop, he comes across like the leaders of the financial institution we have bailed out. Totally out of touch with his pariashioners, he is getting bad advice from those around him

They should reverse this purchase and sell this property.

Posted by: uneasy catholic on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 10:44 AM


Talk about irresponsible actions. We were advised that the Bishop has increased the amount of money he wants to renovate the kitchen in the new, dynamic, vibrant elementary school in Clayton to the tune of $200,000 dollars. Andy Walton tried to justify the spending by saying the price was dropped from $1.5 million to $800,000 dollars. What he failed to mention was that the home was on the market for a year and when the recession/depression hit, it couldn't sell for the original listing price. So the "good catholic family took their money and moved south. How about the $1.7 million dollars for the sale of St. Bridget's school that went toward reducing the debt of that parish rather than helping to support the new elementary school in Clayton. There are too many instances of flagrant misuse of monies by the CEO of the Camden diocese and his constituents to print here. I wonder if they would agree to an audit of how they are spending their monies and make it an open report to the parishioners whose money they are spending. Sounds similar to the AIG scandalous use of taxpayers money with the backing of the government. We are being told by Bishop Galante that he is concerned about the number of Catholics leaving the church, well I suggest he look in the mirror to see how he is a major reason why this is happening.

Posted by: mazz on Mon Mar 16, 2009, 10:58 AM

Today's AC Press has an excellent article about the Diocese of Camden's recent purchase of the $800,000 luxury home in Pittsgrove.  Click here to see the full article. (A similar article can also be found in the well known publication Newsday.) The article was so well-written, excerpts really do not do it justice, but here are a few quotes from Diocesan spinmaster Andy Walton for your entertainment:

But some local Catholics have made much of the description of the new property: Advertised as a "lavish 5-6 bedroom home 11-acre country estate" when it was sold last July, the place boasts riding stables, an elegant fountain in the driveway and a feature described as a "wet bar" inside.

Andrew Walton, spokesman for the diocese, defended the choice of location and style of property for the new convent. "It suits the needs of the sisters, who are looking to expand the order," he said.

He also added that by taking up the new home, the sisters were not going against their vows.

"A vow of poverty has much less to do with where you live than how you live. It's about modest living, but also a poverty of spirit.

"I think there's an undertone of nastiness to some of the commentary, that these sisters' modest living arrangements should come under criticism. There's even that suggestion that, because they're from Kenya, that these arrangements are too good for them."

Andy Walton seems a little defensive - OK, a LOT defensive, even using the race card to try to divert attention from the real issue.  Well, I guess it must be frustrating for him that he cannot clamp down on the AC Press like he does on the Courier-Post (although we know he has tried)! 

Of course, one of the commenters to the article asked how much money Andy Walton makes that he considers an $800,000 home "modest living."  Good question! They could've bought the house I live in for the sisters--five of them, one for each, in fact--and spent the same amount of money. But of course, we have no fountain, wet bar, or stables. Heck, our garage doors don't even work.

Perhaps the most obvious clue to the continual dishonesty coming from the Chancery Offices is this piece of information:

A neighbor, John Langley lives opposite the property. His ancestors, who named the road, used to own most of the area. "Around December, I saw people from the diocese on the property," he recalled. "They said they had come to check it out, and that it might be a residence for the bishop."
Andy suggests that the property will be used in the future as a retreat for the diocese so we, the diocesan faithful, can be continually "formed." Surely it will be the fanciest retreat center we'll have ever been to, but we look forward to experiencing spiritual poverty. It will be so convenient that the new "retreat center" is only a short ride (3.5 miles, to be precise) from St. Mary's. We eagerly anticipate prayer while on horseback and cooling off in the fountain. Who will be tending bar? Pour me one of these.
Since the Sentinel of Gloucester County doesn't have their articles online, we've typed it in here for your purview:

$800,000 EXECUTIVE HOME PURCHASED BY DIOCESE
by Cindy Merckx   IMG_0745

The Sisters of Mary Immaculate Nyeri Convent in Elmer will soon be moving into a beautiful new home in neighboring Pittsgrove Township. The dedicated religious order of sisters is appreciated by many in the community because they take care of the elderly residents at Mater Dei Nursing Home that is located on Route 40, just west of Franklin Township. The Diocese of Camden recently surprised the Sisters with the news of the purchase of a convent.

"We were very surprised," said Sister Bernadette. "We are very happy that  they decided to give it to us." The five sisters have been taking care of the patients of the nursing home and take a vow of poverty like most religious orders. They are not used to extravagant living and they presently live together in a small home in Elmer that has three bedrooms. "It's God's Blessing!" said Sister.

The spacious executive home that was purchased last year by the Diocese for future use as a convent or retreat house.

The property is located at 425 Langley Road in Pittsgrove Township, just off Porchtown Road and was listed by the real estate agent as: IMG_0731"enticingly elegant is this lavish 5-6 bedroom, 11 acre country estate. The white fence surrounds this custom built brick cape home that includes a grand entrance foyer, living/great room with fireplace, dining room, game room with wet bar and sun room. It has fabulous grounds that include a circular driveway with fountain and 3 car attached garage/2 car detached garage and a rear patio. The property has a six stall barn with three run in areas for horses."

On July 22, 2008, the Diocese purchased the property for $800,000. It has been vacant for a year and residents that were interviewed stated they have been concerned as to the status of the property.

According to records obtained at Pittsgrove Township Tax Offices, the property taxes are paid and up-to-date. In 2008 the property taxes for the year were $20,507. The property is listed as QFARM in its assessment. The Diocese has not yet filed an application to change the status of the farm to a convent or other type of institutional classification according to Pittsgrove Township's planning board secretary, yet Walton commented that the tax status of the property was in the process of being changed to 'tax exempt' because it will be used as a convent for the sisters.

Walton was asked why the Diocese decided to by such an expensive home when many parishes are closing and in financial stress.


"The five sisters presently live in a small three bedroom home in Elmer," said Walton. "They will be moving in soon and some furniture has been delivered. The property was offered to the Diocese at a substantial savings and we felt the grounds are an appropriate setting that could be used for a future retreat." *

The future convent is located between the neighboring parishes of St. Ann's in Elmer and St. Mary's of Malaga that are to be either closed or merged.** Parishioners from both parishes expressed concerns when interviewed about the purchase of the property. Some stated that they have questions regarding the Diocese's reasoning behind buying an expensive home for Sisters who take a vow of poverty with many suitable properties for sale in the area at a lower cost.

News reports last year about Bishop Galante selling his shore home to an Italian businessman, Raffaello Follieri, who was accused of scamming real estate investors to purchase Catholic Curch properties, led to rumored talk of the expensive purchase made by the Diocese on this executive property. The Bishop sold his North Wildwood four bedroom townhouse [to Folliri] last year for $400,000. In June 2008, Follieri was jailed on federal fraud and money laudering charges. He was charged with posing as a representative of the Vatican to buy Roman Catholic Church property.

With Diocesan officials deciding to reduce the number of parishes in the Camden Diocese from 124 to 66 in the next few years it will mean that 58 parishes and 24 church buildings will no longer be used for worship.

Parishioners wonder if their Church will be closed and what the future holds for the Catholic Church and its schools. The process of merging parishes has left several parishes staging protests at locations where Bishop Joseph Galante is present. One of the more vocal churches protesting the closing of Churches has been St. Mary's of Malaga, that has been a historical landmark in Franklin Township for over 80 years. The Pastor, Father Jerome Romanowski, has been vocal to oppose the plans to close churches in the Diocese. He was notified last week that he had been transferred by the Bishop to Atlantic City. Romanowski has decided that he will retire.

Several parishioners described the merging effort as tearing the hearts of many of the older parishioners who were instrumental in building the Church.

Diocesan spokesman Andrew Walton explained the reasoning for the decision to merge parishes and stated that by the year 2015 there will only be about 85 priests to serve 124 parishes.

:Every parish is used to having at least one priest serve the parish," said Walton, who stated that the diocese sees these types of protests as 'expected' because of the love the parishioners have for their Church building.***

Walton commented that the number of practicing Catholics has dropped from what it was at 74% in 1960 to 25%. "You have to do something," said Walton. "There are several misconceptions that are out there."

Walton explained that 41 parishes in the diocese can not pay their bills and utilities every month. He stated that this amounts to over 11 million dollars in debt and they can not pay it back.

"One of the misconceptions is when people say that we are trying to sell our properties for profit," Walton said. "All of the property belongs to the parishes. We have no rights to them. All of the assets of the parish leave when yu merge parishes, and none have merged yet." ****

   Editor's Comments/Notes  
* OH MY GOSH! The stuff this guy doesn't come up with, huh?! It's almost entertaining to read. What a creative mind. Andy, Andy, he's our man! If he can't spin it, no one can!

** Just for the record, we will be closed over our dead bodies (so to speak).

*** Of course, Walton is wrong on at least two counts here. St. Mary's and many other area churches that began as missions shared a priest with at least one other church for much of their histories.Returning to a shared-priest scenario would be acceptable to most Catholics. Second, you don't see the Diocese encouraging new vocations, and in fact they seem to be suppressing and discouraging existing priestly vocations by removing priests from the diocese by the dozen on various pretexts. Third, people love The Church, as in, the Bark of Peter, and their Houses of the Lord Jesus are not just buildings. This is heresy. It is Protestantism. Additionally, we must always remember every number spouted by Walton must be questioned as they are usually misleading.

****We have already shown that the "property belongs to the parish" statement often used by the diocese is basically untrue. Read about it here.
An article in today's Gloucester County Times profiles Bishop Galante's as yet unoccupied "McRanchon," as some have called it.  The article also ran in today's Salem County Sunbeam and in today's Bridgeton News. Supposedly this estate was purchased for five religious sisters, but it's been empty for quite some time. Quote:

"Given the need of the sisters and given the fact that the property was being offered to the diocese at such a substantial discount, we've purchased the property for the religious sisters," [diocesan spokesman] Walton said.

But the Council of Parishes of Southern New Jersey, a grass-roots parish organization, said the sisters moving into the house is a knee-jerk reaction on the part of the Diocese of Camden and that it was not its original, intended use.

"We don't believe it," said Leah Vassallo, co-chair of the Council of Parishes. "First of all, it makes no sense. Why should nuns live in what is described as a lavish country estate? It's completely contradictory to what the nuns mission and purpose is." ....

"There's a huge difference between a five-bedroom house and an $800,000 house," Vassallo said.


As you may remember, we covered this back in December here on Savestmarys: Click here to read our expose.

Additionally, The Sentinel of Gloucester County published an article entitled "$800,000 Executive Home Purchased by Diocese" (see next blog article). You'll notice that Andy Walton, IMG_0736spokesman for the Galante Administration, claims that the house was intended for a very small group of religious sisters. Well then why has the diocese let it sit vacant for the better part of a year? And what sisters who've presumably taken a vow of poverty would want or need such a lavish house? Is this one of the "charitable works" that the Bishop's Annual Appeal goes to fund? My own family of four lives in a small post-war house with three very small bedrooms and practically non-existent closets. We're very happy here, but we have taken no vow of poverty. Perhaps we ought to join a religious order and upgrade our lifestyle.

Needless to say, most have long assumed that estate was not originally purchased with the sisters in mind, but for Bishop Galante, possibly for his retirement. But since the Follieri Scandal, which broke July 15th, 2008, exactly one week before the Diocese bought this estate, all eyes have been focused on the various residences of the bishop. So it seems that now they have to move the sisters into the estate home to make it look legit. Or at least, that's the way it appears to most observers we've spoken to about it.

The estate is located here (see map below). As you can see, St. Mary's Malaga is remarkably close by.


View Larger Map

Here is a photo of the stable/horse barn. Who knew the sisters rode horses in their spare time? Perhaps they are one of those obscure equestrian orders.
.IMG_0729
Massive turnout last night at St. Nicholas Parish meeting:

EGG HARBOR CITY- ...about 140 parishioners of St. Nicholas Roman Catholic Church attended a meeting Tuesday night at the Knights of Columbus Hall with hopes of saving their parish.
Read Press of Atlantic City article here

See NJ Churchscape brief piece on historic St. Nick's here.

StNicolas.jpg
St. Nicholas EHC. Check out njchurchscape.com
for more great info on NJ's historic churches.

Overall an excellent job by Rob Spahr, Press writer, with the exception of this misleading information (emphasis ours):

intentions...to cut the number of parishes in the Camden Diocese nearly in half after years of fact finding, analysis and public discussion sessions uncovered a pressing need for downsizing.
Let it be clear: no scientifically reliable facts were found, nor were voices of the faithful listened to in their "years of...public discussions." No one said, "Gee let's close our church because we're not 'vibrant' enough." We only wish the truth about Bishop Galante's wheelings and dealings would be more well known by reminding the public, "After the merger announcement Bishop Galante was found to be financially involved with con artist Raffaello Follieri, now serving a prison sentence, as well as other real estate schemes. Many in the diocese question the true motives for the merger scheme..."

Additionally, too much space was given to Andy Walton, diocesan spinner, umm, I mean "PR guy." Who speaks for the faithful of the diocese? It is sad when a bishop has vested interests for which he must hire a public relations man from outside the state appear less insidious. Isn't that just like a politician? And besides, what ever happened to letting your yea be yea and your no, no? Shouldn't the words of any Christian, particularly a bishop, be clear as crystal and not so vague as to warrant wide interpretation? "Enter ye at the narrow gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there are who go in thereat." (So just in case any of you were in doubt about where St. Mary's and the Council of Parishes stand on the Galante-Vollmer Merge & Close agenda, we're against it.)
 
Nevertheless the Press coverage is laudable and we were very happy to see them cover a topic so dear to so many in South Jersey. We were glad to see the Press reveal the true origin of Galante's "priest shortage," namely, himself. Quote:

The parish already has lost its catechism classes and its resident priest was not replaced after he left in June to serve as an Army chaplain in Europe. It was unclear who will take over once the merger is complete.

Sadly, St. Nick's is far from the only priest in the diocese sent off by Galante to the military chaplaincy in the last year.

And of course, St. Nick's is yet another historic NJ church built with the blood, sweat, tears, and hard-earned money of its parishioners over the years, may they rest in peace!

"It's like losing a part of the family," Terri Cantz, 57, of Egg Harbor City, said of the parish being stripped of services. "My ancestors literally laid the bricks that helped build St. Nicholas and my grandchildren were the fifth generation from my family to attend the St. Nicholas school. This parish is a piece of our upbringing, it's a piece of our character and it deserves to stay here."

Like other parishes reconfiguration schemes in the diocese (Bridgeton, Vineland, etc.), Bishop Galante wishes to promote a segregation scheme at St. Nicholas. It is a shame that in this day and age, a bishop would promote the segregation of large numbers of our Spanish speaking brothers and sisters in Christ. Meanwhile, folks at St. Nick's are not only fighting to keep their parish open, but to remain integrated. Said Jim McGeary,

And the Hispanic parishioners who attend St. Nick's will not be able to maintain the (necessary attendance levels) on their own. You need everyone.
That's the bottom line, isn't it? We are the body of Christ, and in the body, you cannot exclude one part from the other. We need each other.

The will of God is what needs to be heeded at all times. The question remains in our minds, does Bishop Galante care what God wants? We are one body, and the church segregation plans tend to unnecessarily divide us.

But all these things one and the same Spirit worketh, dividing to every one according as he will. For as the body is one, and hath many members; and all the members of the body, whereas they are many, yet are one body, so also is Christ. For in one Spirit were we all baptized into one body, whether Jews or Gentiles, whether bond or free; and in one Spirit we have all been made to drink. For the body also is not one member, but many. If the foot should say, because I am not the hand, I am not of the body; is it therefore not of the body? And if the ear should say, because I am not the eye, I am not of the body; is it therefore not of the body? If the whole body were the eye, where would be the hearing? If the whole were hearing, where would be the smelling? But now God hath set the members every one of them in the body as it hath pleased him. And if they all were one member, where would be the body? But now there are many members indeed, yet one body...God hath tempered the body together, giving to that which wanted the more abundant honour, That there might be no schism in the body; but the members might be mutually careful one for another. And if one member suffer any thing, all the members suffer with it; or if one member glory, all the members rejoice with it. Now you are the body of Christ, and members of member. 1Corinthians 12:11-27

And he gave some apostles, and some prophets, and other some evangelists, and other some pastors and doctors, For the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ: Until we all meet into the unity of faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the age of the fulness of Christ; That henceforth we be no more children tossed to and fro, and carried about with every wind of doctrine by the wickedness of men, by cunning craftiness, by which they lie in wait to deceive. But doing the truth in charity, we may in all things grow up in him who is the head, even Christ: From whom the whole body, being compacted and fitly joined together, by what every joint supplieth, according to the operation in the measure of every part, maketh increase of the body, unto the edifying of itself in charity. (Ephesians 4:11-16)

May God richly bless St. Nick's for their faithfulness to God and their perseverance in the Truth. May none of us be fooled by the "cunning craftiness" of the devil.

Gloucester County Times Article

This past Sunday the Gloucester County Times published a piece on the Diocesan mergers.  Our favorite spokesperson, Andy Walton, was interviewed. 

"The priest conveners and core teams will begin meeting monthly in January to begin work directly involved in preparing the parishes. The bishop has announced his intentions, but there won't be mergers until the core teams and conveners tell the bishop of the parishes' readiness and he issues a decree formally establishing that new parish."

We don't place much confidence in what the diocese says, but for what it's worth, make sure your core team members know how you feel about the merger, because they (theoretically at least) will be the ones who decide when to pull the plug.

Walton said that some parishes will be able to come together more quickly, especially those who wish to expedite the process and have been working together since the announcement last spring.

Click here to see GCT article.  It also ran in the Salem Sunbeam on Monday.  They also interview Leah, who explains the position of the Council of Parishes.

You know, I am all about merging those parishes that wish to be merged and closing those churches that wish to be closed.  I am skeptical that there are many in this category, but for those that are, by all means, knock yourselves out.  But don't merge those parishes that do not wish to be merged!  After a few years, if the mergers of the parishes that want to be merged are in fact successful, there would surely not be so much resistance to other mergers.  But so far, that hasn't happened. 

I've talked to people from the three previous mergers in the Diocese of Camden (St. Michael and Our Lady of Victories in Minotola/Landisville, St. Mary's and Our Lady of Pompeii in Vineland, and Sacred Heart and St. Lucy in Cedarbrook/Blue Anchor) and all have said that the mergers were horrible and are rough even now, years later.  One used the expression that "there was blood in the streets."  And these were mergers under ideal circumstances - where the both churches were staying open ("primary worship sites") and the communities were already close and had much in common.

Imagine how much worse it would be for new proposed mergers, where churches are closing and the parishes sometimes have little in common.  For instance, the St. Mary's (Malaga), St. Rose (Newfield), Queen of the Angels (Minotola and Landisville) and Our Lady of the Lakes (Collings Lakes) merger spans parts of at least four (Gloucester, Atlantic, Salem, Cumberland), and I believe five counties (also Camden), and around a dozen or so municipalities.  Children from this proposed parish would attend high schools from Woodstown to Hammonton, and Vineland to Williamstown (plus Buena, Delsea, Schalick, and others).  In fact, according to Google maps, the travel time from one end of the proposed new parish to the other is around 30 minutes.  It's clear that nobody thought this out intelligently.  And this is just one of many, many examples of failures of the program/process. 

Also, as a note, even though all six churches of the mergers from a few years ago stayed open, at least two will now be closing in this round of mergers.  So don't feel secure in your primary or secondary worship site status.  It can and will change in the next round of mergers, which has already been alluded to by Fr. Gregorio in an August letter to the editor of the Cape May County Herald:

Again if you were the bishop, and you knew that the average diocesan priest today is 64, and that only 12 men are in all stages of seminary theological training, and that many times that will retire or die by 2015, what would you do? What will the average age be in 2015? By then, the bishop will be forced to do another, even more painful consolidation. Fair-minded people are saying this bishop had the courage to do what two or three previous bishops should have done since they had the same demographics.

No, Fr. Gregorio, fair-minded people are saying maybe the three previous Bishops were right and it is Galante who is mistaken.  I never appreciated DiMarzio so much as I do now.

Petition

Please email us at info@savestmarys.net if you would like your name added to the petition. Thank you and God bless you!

I always made an effort to stress that the parish is not an accidental collection of Christians who happen tolive in the same neighborhood...Through careful listening to the word of Scripture and sound instruction in the faith they are enabled to experience their lives, and the life of the parish, as a dynamic sharing in the history of salvation. That experience, in turn, becomes a powerful motive for evangelization.
                                                                        -Pope John Paul II (1998)

We, the undersigned, strenuously object to the closing and merging of St. Mary's in Malaga and all other vibrant, viable parishes within the Diocese of Camden. In addition to providing the Sacraments and fostering out spiritual growth, our parishes have many active groups providing spiritual and material assistance to those in need in our communities. Closing and merging parishes in our neighborhoods is not only unnecessary and devastating to the parishioners, but it is also detrimental to many communities within the Diocese of Camden. Furthermore, we vigorously oppose the sale and future use of church properties for anything but that for which they were originally intended--the Catholic Christian worship of God. We pray you will reconsider your actions and reverse this decision.

                                                               NAME                                           TOWN

1

Al DeValerio

Newfield

2

Alberta Winkler

N. Vineland

3

Alex Benarba

Clayton

4

Alexia Farside

Vineland

5

Alexis Ramos

Malaga

6

Alice Obert

Clayton

7

Alicia Rivera

Clayton

8

Allen Kerski

Clayton

9

Allison Sieminski

Glassboro

10

Alysha Chambers

Elmer

11

Amanda Bosco

Malaga

12

Amanda Kelleher

Newfield

13

Amanda Rippel

Frankinville

14

Amee Muller

Clayton

15

Amy Chamberlin

Franklinville

16

Amy Ryan

Clayton

17

Ana Sales

Williamstown

18

Andrea Craig

Clayton

19

Andrea Marcellina

Williamstown

20

Andrew E. Kilroy

Malaga

21

Andrew J. Moore

Clayton

22

Andrew J. Moore, Sr.

Clayton

23

Andrew Kasper

Clayton

24

Andrew Nelson

Clayton

25

Andrew Schifano

Colts Neck

26

Andrew Vassallo

Newfield

27

Angel DeMaro

Glassboro

28

Angel Gaull

Clayton

29

Angel Lugo

Clayton

30

Angela Gaull

Clayton

31

Angela Ledzinski

Clayton

32

Angelina Rutkowski

Elm 

33

Ann Waldman

Clayton

34

Anna Chamberlin

Franklinville

35

Anna Mackewick

Clayton

36

Anne Bauer

Clayton

37

Anne Hercy

Williamstown

38

Anne Teta

Clayton

39

Annette Rumph

Clayton

40

Annie Brunner

Clayton

41

Anthony DelPalazzo

Voorhees

42

Anthony M. Colache

Williamstown

43

Anthony Rizzo

Newfield

44

Anthony Roman

Franklinville

45

Anthony Yoworsky

Clayton

46

Anthony Ramos

Malaga

47

Antoinette Boylan

Clayton

48

Aracelis Acosta

Clayton

49

Ashley Lehman

Franklinville

50

Ashley Preine

Franklinville

51

B.T. Lilimore

Pittsgrove

52

Barb Liescko

Pittsgrove

53

Barbara Ann McCann

Pittsgrove

54

Barbara Carrigan

Williamstown

55

Barbara DeValerio

Newfield

56

Barbara Sage

Clayton

57

Benancio Espinal

Clayton

58

Bernie Blatt

Forest Grove

59

Betty Fischer

Malaga

60

Beverly Stiner

Clayton

61

Bill Boeckle

Glassboro

62

Bill Cipollone

Malaga

63

Bill Dalessandro

Malaga

64

Bill Laner

Franklinville

65

Bill Roberts

Clayton

66

Billy Cipollone

Malaga

67

Bob Raymond

Clayton

68

Brad Pantaleo

Malaga

69

Bradley Smith

Franklinville

70

Brandon Maynor

Millville

71

Brendan Kirby

Clayton

72

Brian Dean

Monroeville

73

Brian Dtari

Clayton

74

Brian Schifano

Colts Neck

75

Brittney Shaw

Clayton

76

Bryan Burkert

Franklinville

77

Buddy Craig

Franklinville

78

C. Daugherty

Malaga

79

Caitlin Brandon

Mantua

80

Cara Esposito

Clayton

81

Carleigh Gallardo

Pittsgrove

82

Carlo Profico

Clayton

83

Carmella Castelli

Malaga

84

Carole Trace

Malaga

85

Carolyn H. Gant

Franklinville

86

Casey Flory

Clayton

87

Cathy Culle

Clayton

88

Cecelia Trace

Malaga

89

Charles Chamberlin

Franklinville

90

Charles Schifano

Colts Neck

91

Charles Zanetich

Clayton

92

Charlie Bosco

Malaga

93

Chelsea Cossaboon

Newfield

94

Cherisse Watson

Clayton

95

Cheryl O'Hara

Clayton

96

Chris Colache

Williamstown

97

Chris Godfrey

Pitman

98

Christopher C. Sever

Clayton

99

Christopher Russell

Clayton

100

Christopher Senor

Franklinville

101

Chuck Esposito

Clayton

102

Chuck Grinnell

Clayton

103

Cindy Burgess

Franklinville

104

Cletus S. Beckel

Pittsgrove

105

Clifford Taylor

Malaga

106

Colleen Kohn

Clayton

107

Confesora Caban

Clayton

108

Corie Brandon

Mantua

109

Courtney McHale

Mullica Hill

110

Cynthia Merckx

Malaga

111

Cynthia Trasferini

Malaga

112

Cynthia Hetzler

Sewell

113

D.L. Marion

Turnersville

114

Dakoda Maynor

Millville

115

Damien Colache

Clayton

116

Dan Sommeling

Clayton

117

Dan Vassallo

Malaga

118

Danali Young

Clayton

119

Daniel Oyola

Clayton

120

Daniel Ramos

Malaga

121

Danielle Chamberlin

Clayton

122

Danielle McCord

Clayton

123

Danielle Pantaleo

Malaga

124

Danny Farside

Vineland

125

Dante Colache

Williamstown

126

Dave O'Brien

Pittsgrove

127

David Dowonta

Clayton

128

David Hughes

Clayton

129

Dawn M. Meyers

Clayton

130

Deb Ragone

Clayton

131

Debbie Iuliucci

Malaga

132

Debbie Sauer

Clayton

133

Deborah Luchay

Mullica Hill

134

Deborah Lugo

Clayton

135

Deborah Zanetich

Clayton

136

Debra A. Dougherty

Newfield

137

Denise Battle

Clayton

138

Denise Brandon

Mantua

139

Denise Miller

Clayton

140

Denise Morton

Clayton

141

Denise Shaw

Clayton

142

Dennis Zanetich

Clayton

143

Derek Flory

Clayton

144

Diane Hitzelberger

Clayton

145

Diane Trace          

Malaga

146

Diane Vassallo

Newfield

147

Dick Hughes

Clayton

148

Dino Atencio

Clayton

149

Dino DiCastelano

Franklinville

150

Dolores Lafferty

Malaga

151

Dolores Pfeuffer

Erial

152

Dolores Podsiadlo

Elmer

153

Dom DiPetro

Glassboro

154

Domenic Russo

Clayton

155

Domenica Trace

Malaga

156

Donald Keppen

Clayton

157

Donna Andrea

Clayton

158

Donna Kirby

Clayton

159

Donna Wilson

Malaga

160

Doris DeMatteo

Malaga

161

Doris Ruppel

Malaga

162

Dorothea Bosco

Clayton

163

Dorothy Erwin

Clayton

164

Dorothy Horady

Franklinville

165

Doug Ramos

Malaga

166

E.T. Selinger

Clayton

167

Earl L. Prous

Williamstown

168

Edward Mackewick

Clayton

169

Edward Wisowaty

Clayton

170

Eileen Scholl

Franklinville

171

Eleanor Donato

Vineland

172

Elesio Vianlargo

Clayton

173

Emil Lettica

Clayton

174

Emilie O'Hara

Clayton

175

Emily Atkinson

Sicklerville

176

Enrique Caban

Clayton

177

Eric Barrett

Clayton

178

Erika Zaruba

Franklinville

179

Ethel A. Pozzi

Clayton

180

Ethel DeFeo

Malaga

181

Eugene Melnyk

Franklinville

182

Evelyn M. Acevedo

Vineland

183

Feyance Previtt

Clayton

184

Fr. Jerome Romanowski

Malaga

185

Fran Emmons

Franklinville

186

Fran Schultz

Malaga

187

Fran Zeilman

Malaga

188

Francine Repice

Malaga

189

Francis Kelley Heiland

Hammonton

190

Frank DiCicco

Clayton

191

Frank Obert

Clayton

192

Frank Richer

Newfield

193

Franny Papiano

Malaga

194

Fred Ronzo

Williamstown

195

Frederick H. Blauth

Vineland

196

G. E. Brusizaker

Clayton

197

G. J. Swanson

Clayton

198

G. T. Swanson

Clayton

199

Gabrielle Preine

Mullica Hill

200

Gail Perino

Malaga

201

Gary Eastlack

Clayton

202

Gary Smith

Franklinville

203

Gary Zanetich

Clayton

204

Gemma Vassallo

Newfield

205

Gene Melnik

Bluebell

206

George Steinfield

Newfield

207

Georgetta Bucci-Bruno

Newfield

208

Gina Bosco

Malaga

209

Gina Trasferini

Malaga

210

Glemin Fabey

Clayton

211

Glen Ruppel

Franklinville

212

Glen Scott Ruppel, Sr.

Franklinville

213

Glenn D. Moore

Clayton

214

Glenn O'Brien

Pitman

215

Grace Lawrence

Clayton

216

Grace Carlson

Mt. Ephraim

217

Greg Duva

Hammonton

218

Gregory Profico

Clayton

219

Gregory Sentz

Newfield

220

Haley Colache

Clayton

221

Hannah Flory

Clayton

222

Harold Sims

Malaga

223

Harry McGruray

Franklinville

224

Helen Durham

Clayton

225

Helen Kilroy

Malaga

226

Helen O'Hara

Clayton

227

Herb Pfeuffer

Erial

228

Holly A. Flory

Clayton

229

Holly Fabey

Clayton

230

Iesha Torreibeu

Clayton

231

Irene Mick

Franklinville

232

Isabel Furtan

Clayton

233

J. Jess

Franklinville

234

J. Wengert, Sr.

Franklinville

235

J.J. Ruppel, Sr.

Malaga

236

Jac-lyn Zeilman

Malaga

237

Jacob Keppen

Clayton

238

Jacqueline Hetzler

Sewell

239

Jake Baluch

Clayton

240

Jake Muller

Clayton

241

James A. Castrelli, Jr.

Vineland

242

James Castrelli

Vineland

243

James Chamberlin

Franklinville

244

James Kelleher

Newfield

245

James Sieminski

Glassboro

246

Jamie Smith

Clayton

247

Jane Bruno

Clayton

248

Janet Walker

Bridgeton

249

Janet Webekind

Newfield

250

Janice Bosco Tacka

Palmyra, PA

251

Janit Peilher

Vineland

252

Jared Pennisi

Sewell

253

Jason Lapin

Clayton

254

Jason Lipsett

Clayton

255

Jayme Zeilman

Malaga

256

Jean R. Liberto

Blue Anchor

257

Jean Wacker

Clayton

258

Jennifer Cipollone

Malaga

259

Jennifer Hetzler

Newfield

260

Jennifer Olsen

Clayton

261

Jennifer Rowedda

Clayton

262

Jerry DiCicco

Clayton

263

Jerry Velazquez

Newfield

264

Jessica Eastlack

Clayton

265

Jessica Kasper

Clayton

266

Jessica Kelleher

Newfield

267

Jessica Lincoln

Clayton

268

Jessica Parker

Malaga

269

Jessica Zeilman

Malaga

270

Jewel Sauder

Clayton

271

Jill Sommeling

Clayton

272

Jillian Fabey

Clayton

273

Jim Brown

Clayton

274

Jim Waterman

Mullica Hill

275

Joan Carrigan

Williamstown

276

Joan Goodwin

Williamstown

277

Joan Stone

Malaga

278

Joan Wokveck

Clayton

279

Jo-Ann Annie Zeilman

Malaga

280

JoAnn Betz

Vineland

281

Joann Halg

Pittsgrove

282

Joann Laner

Franklinville

283

JoAnn Mills

Malaga

284

Joann Young

Clayton

285

Jo-Ann Zeilman

Malaga

286

Joanna Vassallo

Newfield

287

Joanne Canken

Clayton

288

Joanne Esposito

Clayton

289

Joanne Ryan

Clayton

290

Jocelenn Zaya

Vineland

291

Jody Nelson

Clayton

292

Joe Bruno

Clayton

293

Joe Podsiadlo

Elmer

294

Joe Revelas

Swedesboro

295

Joe Sansalone

Malaga

296

Joe Young

Clayton

297

Joey Russo

Clayton

298

Johamil Salcedo

Clayton

299

Jo-hanna Zeilman

Malaga

300

John Bryozowski

Malaga

301

John Gravenor

Malaga

302

John Griffis

Clayton

303

John Hetzler

Sewell

304

John Jakymczuk

Malaga

305

John Morton

Clayton

306

John Sarill

Clayton

307

John Shaw

Clayton

308

John Tiffany

Clayton

309

John Trovati

Clayton

310

John-Anthony Hetzler

Sewell

311

Jon Lawrence

Clayton

312

Jonathan Shaw

Clayton

313

Jos. U. Dorys

Newfield

314

Jose Del Carmen Espinal

Clayton

315

Joseph Coleman

Clayton

316

Joseph Kelton

Malaga

317

Joseph Nardalli

Franklinville

318

Joseph P. Moffa

Malaga

319

Joseph Sparks

Mullica Hill

320

Josh Griffis

Clayton

321

Josh Parker

Malaga

322

Joshua DeQueter

Clayton

323

Joshua Vassallo

Alloway

324

Juan Oyola

Clayton

325

Juanda Fernandez

Clayton

326

Judith Pidgeon

Wilmington, DE

327

Judith Preine

Pittsgrove

328

Julia Hetzler

Sewell

329

Julia Roman

Clayton

330

Julia Trovati

Clayton

331

Juliana Sieminski

Glassboro

332

Julie DeMarchi Heiland

Hammonton

333

Julie Kirk

Clayton

334

Julie Lincoln

Clayton

335

June Cairone

Malaga

336

Justin Shaw

Clayton

337

Karen DeFrank

Clayton

338

Kat Roberts

Clayton

339

Kathie J. Ramos

Malaga

340

Kathleen Castelli

Vineland

341

Kathy DiStefano

Sicklerville

342

Kathy Mensinger

Franklinville

343

Katie Griffis

Clayton

344

Kellie Kasper

Clayton

345

Kenneth Zanetich

Clayton

346

Kevin Clinch

Franklinville

347

Kevin Kelton

Malaga

348

Kevin Lapin

Clayton

349

Kevin Pain

Clayton

350

Kristin Battestella

Franklin Township

351

L. M. Swanson

Clayton

352

Lance Knisely

Malaga

353

Lane McCord

Clayton

354

Larry Geltzer

Margate

355

Larry Storniola

Franklinville

356

Laura Camma-Resino

Williamstown

357

Laurel Fabey

Clayton

358

Laurie Lettica

Clayton

359

Leah Vassallo

Malaga

360

Len DeFrank

Clayton

361

Len Lapin

Clayton

362

Len Sarill

Clayton

363

Leonard Goodwin

Williamstown

364

Lesley Barrett

Clayton

365

Leslie McFall

Franklinville

366

Lily Kirby

Clayton

367

Linda Bryan

Clayton

368

Linda Persia

Newfield

369

Lisa Bekeshka

Monroeville

370

Lisa Eastlack

Clayton

371

Lisa Lugo

Clayton

372

Lisa Sauber

Clayton

373

Liz Ruggerie

Clayton

374

Loralie Kasper

Clayton

375

Lorenzo

Haddonfield

376

Loretta DiMeo

Franklinville

377

Lorraine Clapp

Clayton

378

Lou Anne Hughes

Clayton

379

Lou Brown

Clayton

380

Lou Kohn

Clayton

381

Lou Kohn, Jr.

Clayton

382

Lou Sgorlon

Vineland

383

Louis Cairone

Malaga

384

Louis Zanetich

Clayton

385

Lucy Davey

Clayton

386

Luis Oyola

Clayton

387

Luis Riviera

Clayton

388

Luis Riviera, Sr.

Clayton

389

Lydia Carrigan

Williamstown

390

Lynn Atkinson

Millville

391

M. Elaine Sware

Clayton

392

M. Geri

Franklinville

393

M. Metz

Clayton

394

Madeline Moffa

Malaga

395

Maegert Claro

Clayton

396

Manny Claro

Clayton

397

Manny Wokveck

Clayton

398

Marco A. Riviera

Clayton

399

Margaret Bryan

Clayton

400

Margaret Wallace

Franklinville

401

Marge Kirsch

Clayton

402

Marge Lapin

Clayton

403

Maria Bella

Clayton

404

Maria DiCicco

Clayton

405

Maria Espinal

Clayton

406

Maria Ronzo

Williamstown

407

Mariann Metz

Clayton

408

Marie Bancroft

Malaga

409

Marina L. Stewart

Newfield

410

Marisel Rivera

Vineland

411

Mark Atkinson

Millville

412

Mark Morton

Clayton

413

Mark Ramos

Malaga

414

Marlene Alston

Clayton

415

Marlene Castelli

Malaga

416

Martin Kelley

Hammonton

417

Mary Anne Sena

Vineland

418

Mary DeFeo

Vineland

419

Mary Ellen Waterman

Mullica Hill

420

Mary J. Quinn

Monroeville

421

Mary Johnson

Franklinville

422

Mary Marion

Turnersville

423

Mary Mignogna

Blackwood

424

Mary R. Colache

Williamstown

425

Mary R. Rabne

Vineland

426

Mary Sparks

Mullica Hill

427

Mary Velazquez

Newfield

428

Mary White

Newfield

429

Mary Yoworsky

Clayton

430

MaryAnn Fithian

Franklinville

431

Marybeth Boeckle

Glassboro

432

Marybeth Owens

Clayton

433

Matt Morton

Clayton

434

Maureen Butcher

Pittsgrove

435

Maureen Geri

Franklinville

436

Maureen Kelleher

Newfield

437

Maureen Starling

Pittsgrove

438

Maurice Young

Clayton

439

Megan McCauley

Vineland

440

Megan Pontano

Sicklerville

441

Megen C. Keury

Clayton

442

Melissa Holden

 

443

Melnyk Family

Franklinville

444

Michael A. Cianchetti

Elmer

445

Michael Beer

Clayton

446

Michael Bryan

Clayton

447

Michael Chambers

Elmer

448

Michael Griffish

Vineland

449

Michael Jenkins

Newfield

450

Michael Kelton

Malaga

451

Michael Magliocco

Newfield

452

Michael McHale

Mullica Hill

453

Michael Menginger

Franklinville

454

Michael Pagano

Millville

455

Michael Sarill

Clayton

456

Michelle Boylan

Clayton

457

Michelle Metz

Clayton

458

Miguel Griffish

Vineland

459

Miguelina Salcedo

Clayton

460

Mike Blatt

Forest Grove

461

Mike Gaull

Clayton

462

Mike Lopez

Clayton

463

Mike Lugo

Clayton

464

Mike Vassallo

Malaga

465

Miller Mills

Malaga

466

Molly Atkinson

Sicklerville

467

Mr. S. Velazquez

Newfield

468

Mrs. S. Velazquez

Newfield

469

Nadine Ambrico

Bellmawr

470

Nancy Godfrey

Pitman

471

Nancy Kane

Malaga

472

Nancy Pantaleo

Malaga

473

Nardelli Family

Williamstown

474

Natalie Persia

Newfield

475

Nate Thomas

Clayton

476

Nic Blauth

Vineland

477

Nicholas Deitz

Newfield

478

Nicolas Hrynenko

Newfield

479

Nicole Bacher

Clayton

480

Nicole Hoffer

Clayton

481

Nicole Sieminski

Glassboro

482

Nicolina Candela

Malaga

483

Nicolle Russo

Clayton

484

P. Sarill

Clayton

485

Pat McCauley

Newfield

486

Pat Schnenberg

Glassboro

487

Patricia A. Mimuy

Clayton

488

Patricia Duva

Hammonton

489

Patricia J. Blauth

Vineland

490

Patricia Lipshultz

Franklinville

491

Patricia Wight

Newfield

492

Patrick DeFeo

Bridgeton

493

Patrick Kelleher

Newfield

494

Paul A. Betz

Vineland

495

Paul Arey

Pine Hill

496

Paul N. Gant

Franklinville

497

Paula Dalessandro

Malaga

498

Paula Melnyk

Franklinville

499

Pauline Blatt

Forest Grove

500

Pauline Taylor

Malaga

501

Pearl Richer

Newfield

502

Peggy Lisinger

Elmer

503

Peggy Pennisi

Sewell

504

Philip Quinn

Monroeville

505

Phillip Colache

Clayton

506

Piera Gravenor

Malaga

507

Pilita Porlucas

Franklinville

508

Polly Sergenti

Clayton

509

Princess Lugo

Clayton

510

Rachel Luchay

Mullica Hill

511

Rachel Ramos

Malaga

512

Ralph Cleo

Frankinville

513

Ralph Travaglione

Franklinville

514

Ramona Sansalone

Malaga

515

Rashawn Previtt

Clayton

516

Ray Gonzalez

Clayton

517

Regina Arey

Pine Hill

518

Regina Farside

Vineland

519

Regina Sims

Malaga

520

Renata Colache

Clayton

521

Renee Hubbard

Newfield

522

Renee Maurer

Malaga

523

Rev. Gannon

Cherry Hill

524

Rich Albano

Clayton

525

Rich Kilroy

Malaga

526

Richard E. Doone III

Franklinville

527

Richard Krug

Clayton

528

Richard Lincoln

Clayton

529

Richard P. Craig, Jr.

Clayton

530

Richard Webekind

Newfield

531

Rickie Krug

Clayton

532

Rita Alvino

Franklinville

533

Rita Griffiths

Vineland

534

Robert Ambrico

Bellmawr

535

Robert Furtan

Clayton

536

Robert Godfrey

Pitman

537

Robert Johnson

Franklinville

538

Robert Lawrence

Clayton

539

Robert White

Newfield

540

Ron Iuliucci

Malaga

541

Ron Vassallo

Alloway

542

Ronald Vassallo

Newfield

543

Rosalie B. Moore

Clayton

544

Roselee Papiano

Malaga

545

Rossi Family

Franklinville

546

Rubea Luciano

Clayton

547

Russell Buck

Clayton

548

Ruth Sottile

Clayton

549

Ryan Jenkins

Minotola

550

Sam Campbell

Willimstown

551

Sam DiStefano

Sicklerville

552

Sam Lopez

Clayton

553

Sammy Steenland

Newfield

554

Sandy DelPalazzo

Voorhees

555

Sandy VanDelft

Clayton

556

Sara Melnyk

Franklinville

557

Sara Truluck

Clayton

558

Scott Bryan

Clayton

559

Scott J. Sievers

Vineland

560

Shannon Muller

Clayton

561

Sharyn Beckel

Pittsgrove

562

Shawn Krug

Clayton

563

Sheena Otto

Franklinville

564

Sheila Smith

Clayton

565

Shelby Patrick

Malaga

566

Shirley Rumph

Clayton

567

Shonna Cooper

Clayton

568

Somer Knisely

Malaga

569

Stacey Yenelli

Clayton

570

Stephanie Kelton

Malaga

571

Stephanie Starling

Pittsgrove

572

Steve Martin

Clayton

573

Steve Yoworsky

Clayton

574

Steven Velazquez

Newfield

575

Sue DiCicco

Clayton

576

Sue Griffis

Clayton

577

Sue Hofer

Malaga

578

Susan Benarba

Clayton

579

Syed Benarba

Clayton

580

T. M. Swanson

Clayton

581

T. Mick

Franklin Twp.

582

Taylor Trace

Malaga

583

Theodore K. Heiland

Hammonton

584

Theresa Borda

Glassboro

585

Theresa Carlson

Mt. Ephraim

586

Theresa Keppen

Clayton

587

Theresa Paleri

Clayton

588

Therese Rizzo

Newfield

589

Thomas Bosco

Malaga

590

Thomas K. Metz

Clayton

591

Tim Carlson

Mt. Ephraim

592

Timothy Trace

Malaga

593

Tina Hayden

Franklinville

594

Tina Young

Clayton

595

Tita Lugo

Clayton

596

Tom Luchay

Mullica Hill

597

Tom Profico

Clayton

598

Tony Bauer

Clayton

599

Tony Brown

Clayton

600

Tony Yoworsky

Clayton

601

Tony Ramos

Malaga

602

Traci Atencio

Clayton

603

Trevor Blauth

Vineland

604

Tyler McCord

Clayton

605

Valerie Schifano

Colts Neck

606

Vanessa Caban

Clayton

607

Vanessa Hughes

Clayton

608

Vannessa Omari

Clayton

609

Veneranda Ramos

Malaga

610

Vicki Taggart

Clayton

611

Vincent Paglioni

Clayton

612

Vincent Sware

Clayton

613

Virginia Wacker

West Collingswood Heights

614

Viva Mackey

Clayton

615

Vivian Hamilton

Clayton

616

Walter Schultz

Malaga

617

Walter W. Clapp

Clayton

618

Werfy Fernandez

Clayton

619

William F. Walker

Franklinville

620

William T. Steenland

Vineland

621

Yasmin Espinal

Clayton

622

Yohanny Salcedo

Clayton

623

Zac Gaull

Clayton

624

Zachary Farside

Vineland

625

Zory Caban

Clayton

626

Zuleyka Salcedo

Clayton

627

Edward Zeuner

Hainesport

Quote:

Parishioners at St. Vincent Pallotti in Haddon Township, pushing to halt a planned merger with nearby St. Aloysius, have won formal permission to proceed with their campaign to reverse the decision, an activist group claimed Wednesday.

The Rome-based Congregation for the Clergy, in a recent letter, has indicated that Friends of St. Vincent Pallotti Inc. may follow a formal process through the Vatican to challenge the local merger plan, according to the Friends group.

"We've tried to do this on a local level. We've tried to address this with the (Camden) Diocese and try to rectify this in a respectful manner through local procedures," said parishioner Ed Pierzynski, a leader of the Friends group. "When that doesn't work, you have some other options."


Read the entire Courier Post Article.

And there's more. (Andy! Andy! He's our man! If he can't spin it, no one can! How's this PR guy, Andy Walton, sleep at night with all that spills out of his mouth from day to day?)

Quote:

But under the latest version, St. Vincent Pallotti will remain a regular worship site, even as it merges with St. Aloysius, Walton said. St. Aloysius would be the base of the merged parish.

Galante "has listened to and consulted extensively with the (Pallotti) parish" and revamped the reorganization "in keeping with (parishioners') own recommendations," Walton said.

They change their rationales and grand plans from day to day, depending upon what suits them. But then, that's the nature of lies. Luckily, we doubt anyone believes anything they say anymore. What's going on in this diocese is an absolute anathema. We need a bishop and holy priests and leaders in this diocese who tell nothing but the Truth and have only Our Lord and His Blessed Mother, the Holy Angels and Saints as their models. May God preserve us from these unholy and diabolical schemes. Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI, send us some relief!!!
Quote:

An analysis of tax rolls across the diocese's territory reveals churches worth a total of about $59 million. Add other parish holdings - from rectories to gardens to vacant lots, as well as affected missions that are expected to merge with parishes - and the land is worth more than $89 million.

These lots cover hundreds of acres across six counties and occupy sites next to highways and bayside towns.

They include a $27 million church site at St. Vincent Pallotti, in Haddon Township, Camden County, whose property includes a school that will not be closed - and St. Anthony's Mission in Commercial Township, Cumberland County, assessed at $129,200.


Shocking! The churches the bishop and Roger McGrath wish to close are sitting on properties worth a whole lot of money?! Who would've thought?! It's pretty hard not to notice. A thoroughly researched article by Juliet Fletcher of the AC Press, who does well to expose the obvious. Do give it a read.

Click here to read article.


For your entertainment, we present the comedic Andy Walton (spokesman for the Diocese) statement of the day:

"All parishes have assets. And some have debts," he said. "And sometimes, by merging a financially struggling parish with another one, you create a single, more vibrant one."
Voi la! Just like that, we have magic! Amazing. Only in real life, Mr. Walton, it's the parishes that are on financially shaky ground that would be closed, not the ones most financially secure. Kind of like saying -600,000 + 300,000 = vibrant. Huh? Vibrant isn't an answer. It seems like when Mr. Walton and Bishop Galante cannot produce a logical explanation for a decision, they simply insert a "V"-word, like "vibrant" or "vital." Yet there are so many other good "V" words, why limit oneself to only two? Why not try "vigorous," "vociferous," "virtuous," "victorious,"  or even "vile"?*

The bottom line is, money (ie, financial security) and "vibrancy" ("pulsating with life, vigor, or activity") are unrelated. "More financially secure" might at least have been a more sensible or consistent term to use, but it still does not follow that life can be found where money is. It is unreasonable to assume that a parish community is not "vibrant" because it lacks money. This is called a post hoc (or false cause) fallacy. Of course, many, many of the churches slated for closure--including St. Mary's--are not in debt anyway, and many--such as St. Mary's--have assets, so the premise is false also.

In a way, it's also the fallacy of false dilemma. In the case of church closures, "mergers," etc., many other reasonable options presented by the laity both during and after the "process" have been dismissed out-of-hand and without explanation. In this case, Mr. Walton and the bishop seem to be making the claim that the only reasonable option before us as a diocese, when there is supposedly a problem with finances, is to merge financially unhealthy parishes with financially sound ones, transferring the assets of the one to the other. That, of course, is never the only option, and it certainly is far from being the only good one. And when supposedly lacking priests, they argue, we should reduce parishes and send existing priests out of the diocese. Well why not try what Archbishop Burke did in St. Louis when faced with a similar problem?

But who has time to chronicle all the odd reasoning that comes out of the chancery office? After all, what's going on here has little to do with logic, the guidance of the Holy Ghost, a desire to foster vocations to the priesthood, or a hunger to save souls and bring them closer to Christ and His Church. Sadly, one wonders if anybody listens to or believe Andy Walton anymore? Besides not residing in the diocese or even the state of NJ (he's just a hired PR man, not a concerned member of the diocese), his inconsistent and illogical rhetoric has become comedic at this point. It is sad when the faithful do not feel that they can trust what comes out of the diocese because core church leaders and officials have lost their credibility. Do we even need to comment on the following statement? Do we really need to remind the diocese of the use of false analogies (not to mention ridiculous ones) and fallacious reasoning generally?

"Attachment to the building itself is a reality. They say, when you move ... it's one of those life events that's on a par with a death in the family," he said. "But at the same time, how many of us still live in the house we lived in as children?"
HUH?

(By the way, thanks to all of you who sent us the link to this article and for your input. It goes without saying that we must, must, MUST continue to pray for the conversion of the bishop and for God's will to be done above all!)

*Interestingly, there's also the Blessed Virgin Mary, Our Lady of Victories, who we venerate, but how often to you hear her name being invoked by those in the chancery office?
Basically, spokesman Andy Walton has passed the buck to Our Holy Father, Pope Benedict  XVI, by claiming that the Vatican instructed Bishop Galante and Company to court Follieri. Anyway, if you're interested in one person's take on this line of defense (a non-Catholic, but I don't particularly think that matters), click here.

Support the Campaign!

Why Save St. Mary's?

What's true for OL Queen of Peace, Pitman & Assumption, Wildwood Crest is also true for St. Mary's Malaga:

"The people in Pitman bought that ground and built that church and it belongs to them. You can't just take it away."

-Anthony Mecca, Queen of Peace Parish, Pitman (also on the slate for closure), May 8, 2008

"This is God's house. Let us live here with God as we've done all these years."

-Fred Spiewak, Assumption Parish, Wildwood Crest, June 11, 2008

Frequently Asked Questions

Full list of Frequently Asked Questions about the Church Closings

Recent Entries

Boy, ain't THAT the truth?
Was reading the Bible today and this seemed especially relevant:Take heed to yourselves, and to the whole flock, wherein the…
Oh, well then, it MUST be true!
From the most recent "Catholic" Star Herald:"About a third of the parishes in the diocese are struggling with deficits and…
Losing Her Religion
AnecdoteA funny thing happened the other day. There's a well-known and well-liked lady in our town who has for ages…

Email Signup

Sign up for daily email updates about the campaign.

Enter your email address:

Facebook

Twitter: Savestmarys

Confidential Tip Line

We would like to announce our totally confidential tip line, for anyone with information pertaining to St. Mary's or their own parish, dealings with the diocese, etc. Remember, you need not give your name, or you may if you choose to. Contact us by email: info@savestmarys.net or phone: 856-692-0222 (ask for Leah).